‘Good’ candidates dropping out of the interview process: It’s not always a bad thing…

Nov 14, 2020 by Chris Davies 

As a hiring manager you have found a candidate who impressed you, they have all the skills for the job and fit with your company values. However, before you can take them forward to the next steps, the candidate changes their mind about the position and withdraws their application. Sound familiar? It can be frustrating when this happens, and it can occur for many reasons, but it isn’t always a bad thing if a good candidate drops out of the process.


1.    It is an opportunity to learn


If a candidate does drop out of the process, it is important to understand why that decision has been made. Did they get another offer? If so, find out where that offer came from, what was the role, how quickly did that business move? After attending the interview did the candidate realise that the role wasn’t what they initially thought? it may have not been the right move for them at this time. If you find out why it can help you change any interview processes that need fine tuning, did the job advertisement reflect the position, is their continuity throughout the process about the role and its responsibilities? If they took another offer you can find out what you are competing with in the job market? Was the salary lower? Did location have a hand to play in the candidate’s decision?


2.    It saves you heartache further down the line.


If a ‘good’ candidate withdraws, there is also a possibility that perhaps they weren’t as good as you initially thought. The truth is, every time you invite an applicant to complete an interview you are encouraging them to re-assess the opportunity. If a ‘good’ candidate drops out, there is a possibility they weren’t that good to start with. With that said, you are no longer hiring someone that may not be right for the position and/or business.


3.    You may meet again, don’t know where, don’t know when.


Even if a candidate does drop out, it is also important to leave them with a good impression. It might be the case on this occasion after finding more about the role that it doesn’t quite fit what they are looking for. You may get another requirement in the future that could be a better fit. If you’ve kept that relationship warm, even in previous disappointment, if you’ve thought about the long game, you may indeed land your candidate. This time knowing full well what could bring them to you.


Summary


Remember interviews go both ways, candidates are feeling different companies out. You’ve got to give them an opportunity to learn more about you too. Learning about these things will significantly help you on the next occasion. If it doesn’t work out, you try to gather as much information as possible as to why that may have been and perhaps implement any changes to avoid in the future if possible

Share this article

Share this article

By Chris Davies 13 Nov, 2020
Continuing in the spirit of culture and values, I wanted to look further into how companies perceive themselves. Some say how amazing they are and what they do is ground breaking, that culture is king. However, when we look at current or ex-employees for a lot of businesses, they tend to say something completely different. For example, a business of over 300 people mentions on their website as part of their values being “inclusive” and “doing the right thing”. However, their Glassdoor score i...
By Ben Cantrall 07 Nov, 2020
Sometimes, I think about death. Morbid, even for a recruitment blog! I was recently musing on the nature of eulogies. I imagined a scenario where I had been auditioning for an afterlife. In order to qualify for the afterlife, I had to have inspired a wonderful eulogy. The heavenly gatekeeper wouldn’t let me in unless this was the case (despite having met and personally screened me on several occasions). So, the gatekeeper let me know they needed a 10/10 eulogy. They then asked me to nominate...
By Ben Cantrall 06 Nov, 2020
When I tell people that I am one of 11 children, people typically have the same remarks. Chief among them is incredulous disbelief comparisons to animals quot;are you a rabbit?(no I am not), comments about entertainment options did your parents not have a TV?quot;, knowing remarks about religion quot;Catholic family huh;quot;, the old quot;in this day and age?quot; and in many cases comments about my parents affection which Id rather not bring attention to. Yesterday I asked all my siblings (8 sisters and ...
By Ben Cantrall 05 Nov, 2020
My love affair with TT started years ago. Dad had an old table under the house and one day it meandered up to the back verandah. This table had several dead spots and a slight lean that only endeared it further to me. I have vivid memories of being an 11-13 year old, playing my oldest brother in law, Steve (who would have been 27 at the time) and being soundly, relentlessly beaten. Always. Several tables, 10 years and a bachelor pad later, we had a table in our garage. At one stage I was cloc..
By Chris Davies 13 Nov, 2020
Continuing in the spirit of culture and values, I wanted to look further into how companies perceive themselves. Some say how amazing they are and what they do is ground breaking, that culture is king. However, when we look at current or ex-employees for a lot of businesses, they tend to say something completely different. For example, a business of over 300 people mentions on their website as part of their values being “inclusive” and “doing the right thing”. However, their Glassdoor score i...
By Ben Cantrall 07 Nov, 2020
Sometimes, I think about death. Morbid, even for a recruitment blog! I was recently musing on the nature of eulogies. I imagined a scenario where I had been auditioning for an afterlife. In order to qualify for the afterlife, I had to have inspired a wonderful eulogy. The heavenly gatekeeper wouldn’t let me in unless this was the case (despite having met and personally screened me on several occasions). So, the gatekeeper let me know they needed a 10/10 eulogy. They then asked me to nominate...
By Ben Cantrall 06 Nov, 2020
When I tell people that I am one of 11 children, people typically have the same remarks. Chief among them is incredulous disbelief comparisons to animals quot;are you a rabbit?(no I am not), comments about entertainment options did your parents not have a TV?quot;, knowing remarks about religion quot;Catholic family huh;quot;, the old quot;in this day and age?quot; and in many cases comments about my parents affection which Id rather not bring attention to. Yesterday I asked all my siblings (8 sisters and ...
By Ben Cantrall 05 Nov, 2020
My love affair with TT started years ago. Dad had an old table under the house and one day it meandered up to the back verandah. This table had several dead spots and a slight lean that only endeared it further to me. I have vivid memories of being an 11-13 year old, playing my oldest brother in law, Steve (who would have been 27 at the time) and being soundly, relentlessly beaten. Always. Several tables, 10 years and a bachelor pad later, we had a table in our garage. At one stage I was cloc..
By Ben Cantrall 04 Nov, 2020
In parts of Australia, shit is hitting the fan. In other parts of Australia, fans are hitting the footy. NSW is somewhere in between. Both geographically and metaphorically. I spoke with a friend of mine who runs a Melbourne based business on how he’s dealing with going into lockdown. Ben has been running his business for 15 years. He employs 150 staff across his group of companies, and he has offices in NSW, Queensland, South Australia, Wellington, New Plymouth and Victoria- where he is base..
By Ben Cantrall 04 Nov, 2020
I sat down with a handsome, intelligent, articulate (and extremely youthful looking!) man yesterday for a coffee (work related I assure you). He has a fantastic CV- working with Aussie companies who have become globally known brands over the course of the last few years. His most recent role, however, left him wanting. Being a professional, he didn’t disparage his most recent employer- but it was clear he was disappointed in how it turned out. I asked him what he’d do better next time: “do mo.
By Ben Cantrall 04 Nov, 2020
Put your drink in your left hand. The first piece of advice I received about networking. Moving past what that says about broader alcohol culture or my own habits, let’s talk about…. Networking. A dirty word in the mouths and minds of many. It can conjure visions of conversations that make you feel like a leech- sucking something from someone who doesn’t want to talk with you. Not a great feeling! But here we are. On Linkedin, the home of networking. Where in Australia alone, I’m told by seve..
By Ben Cantrall 04 Nov, 2020
On the 13th of May this year, I became a statistic. My family and I packed up our apartment, picked a removalist I wouldn’t recommend to my worst enemy, put 85% of our belongings in a truck, and left Sydney for the country. When we got out of the car 2 hours later we were in a brave new world- Kangaroo Valley, the home of many a great golf weekend, and many a great romantic weekend, but never my actual home before. Given I’d been in Bondi for 13 years, this was a change. In a deeply personal ...
By Chris Davies 13 Jul, 2020
The above may sound strange, but I really think this might be the case. As a recruiter that works on entry level roles all the way up to senior management, I’m constantly seeing hundreds of applications with zero follow up. For example, earlier this month I posted a senior role to LinkedIn and another job board where I have received 462 (and counting) applications for the one position. Now you might be wondering, why is a recruiter complaining about lots of applicants, surely that’s better
By Chris Davies 13 Jul, 2020
Sydney. The global city, home to over 5 million people, opportunities galore! All of these things are true, but what people might fail to recognise is that it’s actually a pretty small world, particularly when it comes to my experience in dealing with recruitment in the sales and contact centre space over the past 5 years. I find myself coming across the same people repeatedly and if I’ve had some form or interaction/relationship with them I will remember it 99% of the time, regardless of whe..
More Posts
Share by: